inner critic

Protector Parts, Defender Parts

We are rather less a single, unitary 'I' than a system or community of parts, each in relationship with one another. And it can be so very revealing, and practically useful, to get to know the parts - their intelligence, their blind-spots, and the very particular projects they've each taken up in our lives.I've written before here about shame, a familiar background mood for me, as it is for so many people. It turns out that there are at least two parts of me that are actively involved in protecting me from shaming by others - one which pre-emptively shames me, and one which more directly defends me from shame. Each has its own form of good intention, and each often causes me difficulty.The first part is an inner critic part. It's so dedicated to me not being shamed by other people that it will frequently take pre-emptive action by shaming me itself. The logic is clear, and compelling: if I can be made to feel sufficient shame beforehand, then perhaps I'll hold back from acting in a way that would cause others to shame me. It's a simple exchange - the lesser pain of my own internally generated shame to protect against the more soul-searing shame that comes from the disapproval of other people.This is the part which would have me hold back from speaking my mind, from becoming angry with other people, from showing too much love, from being a surprise or a disappointment or a bother or mystery. This is the part which, for years, held me back from dancing, having me be ashamed of myself even before I begin. It's dedicated to forever scanning the horizon and keeping me within very tightly contained boundaries so as to avoid the kind of pain it knows I could, once, not tolerate. It is willing to exact quite a price in order to do this: the inner price of feeling some level of shame at all times, and the outer price of holding back what is, most truly, mine to bring.The second part is a protector part. Should the antics of the inner critic fail, so that I actually get shamed by someone else, it throws itself into action. It's not interested in waiting, nor does it have any time for curiosity or learning. What it most wants is the shame to go away. The protector part brings forward my defensiveness, my justifications, my denial. Insincere apologies, pretence, lengthy justifications for my actions, tuning out, disconnecting from people, freezing, abandoning my commitments, bending myself out of shape - all these are the order of the day for the protector part.The protector part is also willing to pay a price to protect me from shame, most notably having me act at odds with myself, with a relationship I care about, or with my deepest, most sincere commitments.And while both these parts have honourable and noble intentions, they are way out of date, having swung into action when I was very small and really needed some protection. They don't take into account that I am an adult now, and that there is another part of me, more akin to the me-myself that exists over the entire span of my life, that no longer needs their help. This part, which could be called essence or self, is really quite able to be in the world alongside shame, and anger, and hate, and disappointment. It is vast enough, deep enough, alive enough, and quite strong enough to experience whatever comes its way. It is curious, open, timeless, and willing to learn.Naming the parts has power. When I see that I am had by the inner critic or inner protector, I am increasingly able to ask them to relax, to step aside - to reassure them that I'm quite fine, whatever happens, and that I do not need them to protect me any more. And, in the space that this affords, I'm more able to step, willingly and without panic or rush, towards genuine relationship and inquiry, and into the world as it is rather than the world as smaller parts of me imagine it to be.

Photo Credit: ebrandonje via Compfight cc

The parts of ourselves we see in others

There are parts of us we know well - those that are in close - and parts of ourselves we know less well - the more hidden, invisible parts. Sometimes, simply giving a part its appropriate name allows us to see it and to interact with it more skilfully. The inner critic is one such part. Seeing it, naming it, entering into a different kind of relationship and conversation with it - all of these can be powerful moves in having it take up a more helpful and life-giving place in the constellation of entities each of us calls 'I'.But there are also parts of each of us that we have disowned or split off and that we barely see as part of ourselves at all. These may be parts of ourselves that we dislike, or judge, or abhor. Or they can parts we long for, but do not feel are available or appropriate for us. But parts of us they are, and since we can't bear to identify our experience of them with ourselves, we readily project them into others.So often, when we find ourselves disliking other people, when we get irritated by them, feel judgment or scorn or disdain or even hate towards them, we're seeing in them what we most dislike or scorn or are irritated about in ourselves. A simple way of saying this is that what we encounter in them reminds us so strongly of what we're trying to get away from in ourselves, that we try get away from it in them too.The very same process can also be in play with those we are drawn to, admire, or put on a pedestal. In this case perhaps we're seeing in the other, first, a reminder of split-off parts of ourselves that we deeply long to be reunited with but do not consciously know as our own. We feel drawn to the other person, or good about ourselves around them, precisely because of the feeling of wholeness and re-unification it brings about it in us.Perhaps it becomes obvious when described this way that the work for us to do with people who irritate us is not to try to change them (which in any case does not address the primary source of our irritation or anger or frustration) but to find out what it is about ourselves that we dislike so much and work with some effort and diligence to understand, turn towards, and accept it.And with people we love and admire the inner work for us to do is much the same if we want to love and admire them for who they are rather than because a hole or an emptiness or a longing gets filled when we're around them.Then, we can find, it's more and more possible to be around a wider range of people with openness and warmth and genuine regard. And it's also more possible to be close and compassionate with those we love most, who are so often the very people with whom we have the most difficulty because it's in them we find parts of ourselves most readily reflected.  

A quiet and genuine joy

I remember the moment with gratitude, though it was tough at the time."You have no idea how self-judgemental you are", Andy had said to me. And it had cut like a knife. But he was right. I was thirty-five years old and had over many years become seasoned to the harshness of the world.I didn't know it as harshness to be so filled with self-doubt and such worry about how I was doing all the time. It was just the way the world was. Unquestionable. Invisible. And I had no idea that it wasn't so much the world that was harsh but my own inner experience.Andy's carefully timed observation was one of those moments when what had been in the background for so long came crashing into the foreground - when what I had been swimming in for so long was made apparent to me.It was a doorway into a profoundly new world in which I began to see that most of what I thought others were thinking about me was actually what I was thinking about myself. And that I no longer had to believe everything I thought so completely.Eleven years later, I'm still sometimes out-foxed by the shape-shifting cleverness of my inner critic. But I am more often, and more quickly, able to spot it and see through its ways of holding me back and of pulling me apart.And, more and more, in the space that envelops me when it steps aside, I'm able to feel a quiet and genuine kind of joy.

Photo Credit: Kristofer Williams via Compfight cc

 

The four of you

fourpeopleWhen you're talking with another person, remember that there are always more than two of you present.At the very least there's you, and them, and your inner-critic and their inner-critic.Whatever the two of you are visibly up to, there's an often hidden dynamic between the two inner-critics (who work hard to keep themselves invisible) as they jostle to keep you in line, watch out for attacks or supposed attacks from the other, spur you into defending yourself (often times when no defence is called for), have you be insistent or rigid or judging or withdrawn.And each critic spurs the other on, inventing slights and hurts, and anticipating what's it imagines is yet to come.All of this is one reason why you can sometimes look back on a conversation with bemusement and confusion. 'What on earth happened there?' you ask yourself. 'I thought we were only talking about this morning's meeting, but now I feel hurt and uncertain, and so does she'.One way to help yourself and others is to spot all of this and give name to it, at first to yourself. Learn the ways it shows up and what it gets up to when your attention is elsewhere.And then, over time, bring the existence of the critic and all its manifestations into conversation. This takes courage and openness. But bringing the inner critic out of its hiding place allows it to be seen and talked about, and responded to, and lessens its power to manipulate behind the scenes.Your inner world is always making itself known in the outer world, whether you like it or not, and it's true for everyone else too. The more you can give name to, and the more you can bring it forward from its otherwise invisible background, the more chance you'll have of working with it in service of you and everyone around you.

Photo Credit: *m22 via Compfight cc

Hey! I'm Talking to You!

[embed]https://youtu.be/MyA-l7bkwT4[/embed]In this episode, Lizzie and I talk about the inner 'predator' or 'inner critic' force that keeps us small and living - essentially - a life that's not fully our own. We consider the kind of power that's required from each of us to break free of this constraint so we can claim our own lives, and how this inner move is profoundly connected to our capacity to exercise power in healthy and life-giving ways in the world around us.Along the way we consider how it's only really possible to do this work in relationship with others (hence the importance of community, and the contribution of our profession of coaching), and we imagine a world in which the marketing messages that bombard us each day remind us of our dignity, goodness and nobility instead of trying to fuel the critic by showing us how we might 'improve' ourselves all the time.Our source is Jose Enciso's poem 'I'm Talking to You!', reproduced here with Jose's permission.You can find out more about Jose and his work on his website www.setthetruthfree.com

​I'm talking to you!

Long into the nightand still long to the dawnPast the parade of lossesand betrayals of selfwrought of service to the wrong god.Awoken from a fitful slumberbathed in regret and remorse.A protest profound arisesdeep within my grief.A holy howlscreaming at the thief.Hey!  I'm talking to you!Yes, you, in the corner,slinking and smirking.You, who kept me down all these years.You, who gave me crumbsand told me it was a life.This is not my life!This is insecurity,apology,I'm sorry if I offended thee.This is grovel and hovel.Bow downthat will keep you safe and sound.You broke into my houseand rearranged all the furniture.You stole my childhoodand made me a caricature.Hey!  I'm talking to you!I want my life back.Not this check and double check,doubt and re-doubt.Me, the nice guy with no backbone.Me, the nice guy who doesn't even know if he wants Mexican or Chinese.(mmm, I don't know, what do you want?)Me, the noble, beautiful, kind manwho only sees ugliness and embarrassment in your mirror.I have given away too much.I have lain down deep in despair.I have - almost - given up hope.But, you have not won yet.Right now, I'm calling you out.I am not ready to diein a house decorated by someone else. -Jose Enciso

Lizzie Winn and I are live every Sunday morning at 9am UK time for the thirdspace coaching 'Turning Towards Life' project. You can join our facebook group to watch live, view archives, and join in the growing community and conversation that’s happening around this project.

That I would be good

Sometimes we need a simple reminder that behind all our judgements, our self-distrust, our striving to be different from who we are, our perfectionism, our living our lives as a giant and unending self-improvement project, is a basic goodness that we all share. A basic goodness that we quickly forget.This is a topic Alanis Morissette clearly knows about from the inside. Perhaps, today, this song might be just what you were longing to remember.[embed]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QMZReI2QrlQ[/embed]

We don't do introspection

"We don't do introspection", they said to me. "None of this fluffy, self-indulgent, navel-gazing here", they continued. "We do action."

Of course. If you're going to lead as they were, in a global organisation, then right action is critical. But what they meant by "we don't do introspection" was "we aren't prepared to look at ourselves".

If they had an inkling, and most of us do not, of how much their actions were being shaped, out of their view, by

their personal preferences,by their fears,by years of habit,by their avoidance of reminders of childhood experiences (mostly shame),by the expectations their parents handed them,by their inner critic,by their longing to be appreciated, liked, respected, feared, in control

then they would perhaps have taken introspection or some rigorous self-observation more seriously. They would have been brave enough not just to look at their actions, but to look upstream at what was giving rise to them.

But they didn't.

They had asked for help because they'd been amazingly effective in taking action - action that had landed them and their organisation in deep trouble.

And now they were trying to get out, with the same excuses, and by doing more of what had got them into difficulty in the first place.

Crazy, and sadly all too common.

Photo Credit: RomainBihore via Compfight cc

Tight spirals

We discover early in life what the people around us expect from us. And we find ways of doing just that. Even if we've completely misunderstood what was being asked.Meeting these expectations becomes, before long, central to our identity. We know ourselves as this or that kind of person, and then actively work to keep the identity we've established going. It feels familiar and comfortable to keep having people around us respond to us in the way to which we've become accustomed.I learned early on to be the peacekeeper: the pursuer of harmony, making sure I and everyone around me remained undisturbed and untroubled; listening, supporting, staying quiet, defusing conflict, avoiding anger (my own and other people's).All these ways of being seemed, unquestionably, to be me.And of course they affected and shaped what was possible in any kind of relationship with me. Peacekeeping can be a great gift to the world, but also stifling and frustrating for others when anything genuine and troubling and sharp needs to be said.Other people around me took on other kinds of identity - the helper, making sure everyone is cared for and nobody is left out; the achiever, getting ahead and making things happen, knowing themselves through the outward signs of success; the challenger, being sure to be in control, using assertiveness and power to have things happen.We have powerful inner forces that keep us inside the bounds we've established - among them the inner critic, and shame. For years, if I would be ashamed - mortified - if I said anything that I thought might hurt or upset another. And I'd be eaten up by my inner critic if anyone dared express anger towards me.This is such an important topic because most of the time we can't tell that this is what we're doing - manipulating the world so it's just so - not too hot, not too cold, but just as we expect it to be.We lead this way. We relate this way.This is why we all need people around us who can see through our strategies and habits, who can see who we are beyond the tight spiral these identities produce in us - a spiral which keeps the horizons of the world smaller than we imagine, and smaller than we need.

Photo Credit: henrikj via Compfight cc

Wild Geese

Lizzie and I were live again this morning, The source for this week's conversation was Mary Oliver's powerful poem 'Wild Geese'.We talk about the constraining effects of inner criticism and the limits of our over-effort to be good or strong or loving or clever. And along the way we stumble into some realisations about what's possible when we learn to trust something other than our own self-judgement, and reach out to others for help.And if you’d like to join in with the growing community that’s forming around this project, and the lively conversation that’s taking part in the comments, you can do so here.[embed]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zru6Ze_rfRw[/embed]

Balancing Judgement and Mercy

Whatever we say we're most committed to, a great many of us live as if judgement were the primary human value, judging ourselves mercilessly and without respite. And, when we live in the stream of harsh judgement, no effort is enough, no achievement worth much, and our efforts to help seem to us nothing but disguised selfishness. In this relentless stream we find that the only way to bring ourselves to the world with the care and commitment we wish for is to fight an endless battle in which parts of ourselves - our essential goodness and our inner criticism - are pitched against one another.In a battle there's really never any time to rest. We live in state of vigilance, braced and ready for the blows that can come at any moment: for the offhand critical comment from a loved one or colleague, for the figures on our latest bank statement, for a tweet or instagram post that reminds us of all the ways we're falling short.And we find ourselves mounting all kinds of pre-emptive defence: doing our best to look good (which we'll do even at great emotional, spiritual or financial expense), tuning out from our lives with distractions (so as not to feel the difficulty we're in), shaming ourselves (to avoid the pain of being shamed in other ways) or deflating and collapsing (as if hiding from the world will save us).Perhaps the worst of all of this is the way we hide the very battle we're fighting, as if we are the only ones, as if nobody else has it this way. We become convinced that life has to be a battle. And that is our lot to live a life of inner harshness that only adds to whatever harshness and struggle we already experience in the world around us.Nearly all of us are doing this - whether we're teachers or CEOs, politicians or parents, artists or activists or accountants. And the more we live this way, the more exhausted we become, and the fewer of our gifts - the gifts we each have that the world needs from us - we get to bring.All the while that we're caught up in harsh self-judgement (which easily and also becomes harsh judgement of others) we've forgotten that judgement isn't the same as discernment, and that discernment only becomes possible when judgement is balanced by a stream of mercy. I say 'balanced' here, but it seems to me much more the case that true discernment (the kind that can be life-giving, truthful and contributory) only comes into being when judgement is thoroughly infused with mercy - when judgement and mercy pour into one another, illuminate one another, become a single river.And what is mercy? It's a commitment to not turning away. It's dignifying our anguish and confusion, the transience and unpredictability of our lives and the difficulties we've all had to face, and reaching for the essential goodness that is present in all of us. Mercy is indeed our turning towards life itself with a fiercely kind and loving embrace. It's a commitment to see the beauty in our very unfinishedness, to cherish and honour both our inevitable falling-short and our capacity to improve things.Most of us haven't practiced mercy towards ourselves with anything approaching the diligence with which we practice harsh self-judgement.  But until mercy can become a serious part of our constellation of virtues, until we practice it as much as we long for it, we'll struggle with more difficulty than we're due and we'll doubtless bring more difficulty to others than we intend.

Photo Credit: ShinyPhotoScotland Flickr via Compfight cc